THE MONDAY MORNING HI-QUALITY VINYL RIP : Part Fifty-six: METAL POSTCARD (MITTAGEISEN)

I’m going to all academic on you today by lifting loads of words from Masterclass dot com .  I’m not a subscriber, but this article was available to read online, seemingly free of charge.  I’ll likely get into trouble for it.

“Post-punk music is an offshoot of punk rock that embraces greater ambition in terms of harmony, melody, rhythm, and lyrical content while retaining punk energy and urgency. Prominent post-punk bands such as Gang of Four, Wire, Joy Division, The Smiths, Echo & the Bunnymen, Sonic Youth, and Fugazi helped set the stage for the alternative rock explosion of the 1990s.

The post-punk movement closely overlaps with new wave music. While the new wave genre is more closely linked to popular bands like Talking Heads, New Order, Depeche Mode, and Duran Duran, it shared many musicians with the post-punk scene. For instance, Joy Division is often referred to as post-punk, but following the death of singer Ian Curtis, the remaining musicians carried on as New Order, which is widely considered a new wave group. Due to the close relationship between genres, post-punk is sometimes referred to as “no wave” music.

The post-punk scene arose from punk rock. Many post-punk musicians grew up as fans of bands like the Sex Pistols, the Ramones, New York Dolls, and Minor Threat. In some cases, they were actual members of these bands, such as Public Image Ltd frontman John Lydon, who is perhaps better known as Johnny Rotten of The Sex Pistols.

* Post-punk spread: Post-punk music spread throughout the English-speaking world between the late ’70s and the mid ’90s. Major geographic hubs included New York, Washington, Boston, and Chicago, and the English cities of London, Manchester, and Leeds.

* Slight shift from punk: Some post-punks made only a slight departure from the raucous sounds of punk rock. Art rock-influenced groups like The Slits, Pere Ubu, and The Raincoats often sounded on the brink of collapse. Similar groups like The Birthday Party and The Stooges also brought a heaviness, courtesy of respective singers Nick Cave and Iggy Pop.

* Modernization: Other post-punk groups modernized for the 1980s, incorporating new technology, atmospheric layering, and pop hooks. Such groups included synth-pop acts like Duran Duran, Depeche Mode, and New Order.

* Adding rhythm: Yet another branch of post-punk made rhythm a core part of their identity. Bands influenced by dub and reggae included The Police and the Talking Heads, as well as electronic music pioneers in the Krautrock scene, such as Tangerine Dream, Kraftwerk, and Neu!

* A sophisticated sound: The post-punk era continued well into the 1990s and beyond, as groups like Fugazi, Girls Against Boys, Superchunk, Sonic Youth, The Fall, and many more combined punk’s DIY spirit with increased musical sophistication and a subtle knack for pop hooks.

Post-punk is an expansive genre, and different branches contain idiomatic characteristics.

1. Direct punk influence: Many post-punk groups retain the vast majority of the punk ethos and raw power. Groups like Killing Joke, Mission of Burma, and The Birthday Party can sound as intense as standard punk bands.

2. Appreciation for art rock: A large number of post-punks came of age via the psychedelic and avant-garde flirtations of 1970s acts like The Velvet Underground, Throbbing Gristle, David Bowie, and Brian Eno. Pere Ubu, Devo, Bauhaus, and The Raincoats carried on the experimental spirit of these musicians.

3. Embrace of synthesizers: Some post-punk hinges entirely around guitars. Other post-punk acts readily incorporated synthesizer technology, including Depeche Mode and goth rockers The Cure.

4. Jangly guitars: Post-punks who resisted synthesizers were likely to embrace trebly guitars that produced a Byrds-style “jangle.” Such groups included R.E.M., Orange Juice, and The dB’s.

5. Pop hooks: In many cases, punk rockers resisted commercial success at every turn. Many post-punks were far more open to such success and even actively chased it. The pop hooks of Siouxsie and the Banshees, Buzzcocks, R.E.M., Pixies, and Talking Heads differed from the traditional punk era.

6. “Angular” sounds: Post-punk groups like Wire, Gang of Four, and Fugazi were described as “angular.” This appears to refer to their treble-focused guitar amps with minimal reverb, and their choice of guitar riffs and chord progressions that steered clear of the folk music that defined much of early rock ‘n’ roll. This aural sensation would carry on to more contemporary post-punk bands, like Interpol and The Knife.

7. Strong support from music journalists: Unlike other 1980s genres, such as dance pop and hair metal, post-punk received steady praise from music critics. Outlets supported post-punk records like Wire’s 154, PiL’s Metal Box, Gang of Four’s Entertainment!, and Joy Division’s Unknown Pleasures. Groups like the new wave Talking Heads, the gothic rock combo The Cure, and iconoclasts Fugazi were also commended.

It’s clearly written from an American perspective, and I’m guessing by someone quite young who is looking back at things without having lived through the era.  There are some interesting points made along the way, but some of the examples highlighted to support the conclusions seem baffling.

For instance, Siouxsie and the Banshees get a mention late on under the section on pop hooks, which I can understand if you focus solely on the later-era, but it fails to acknowledge and recognise that one of their earliest songs, as included on The Scream (1978) is, in this music fan’s opinion, the definitive post-punk song of them all:-

mp3: Siouxsie and the Banshees – Metal Postcard (Mittageisen)

I always forget that this was re-recorded with German lyrics and released as a double-A sided single, along with Love In A Void, in September 1979, probably because I don’t own a copy of that particular 7″.  But as you know, not owning things doesn’t stop activities at TVV:-

mp3: Siouxsie and the Banshees – Mittageisen (Metal Postcard)

Let’s complete things with the faster-paced Peel Session version, first broadcast on 5 December 1977:-

mp3: Siouxsie and the Banshees – Metal Postcard (Peel Session)

 

JC

6 thoughts on “THE MONDAY MORNING HI-QUALITY VINYL RIP : Part Fifty-six: METAL POSTCARD (MITTAGEISEN)

  1. Interesting. Naive, but interesting.

    This brought a chuckle…

    “5. Pop hooks: In many cases, punk rockers resisted commercial success at every turn.” Ha!

    There seems to be some confusion too between new wave and new romantic, among many other confusions.

    It was written, I surmise, with a view to impress. It doesn’t.

    Still, it resulted in some Siouxsie and the Banshees.

  2. Well, that woke me up this morning- the music not the confusing article, thanks

  3. I would question whether the Stooges were post- punk- given they released all their records prior to punk. And arguably invented punk.

  4. Laughable! As you say, clearly written by a juvenile with limited historical research skills or understanding of music! So, anyway, Siouxsie and the Banshees. I remember the keen anticipation of the release of The Scream. We were literally counting down the hours to release day. Two weeks before it was due in the shops John Peel played the whole album without interruption from beginning to end on his show, no doubt to the intense dismay of Polydor and Peel’s bosses at the BBC. We all dutifully recorded it straight off the radio, of course, but then equally obviously we all rushed to Phoenix on Edinburgh High Street the minute it landed and bought it, despite being already intimately familiar with its contents. So much for ‘home taping is killing music’. Despite many, many plays, my copy of The Scream has been carefully preserved in a plastic sleeve (something I don’t normally do) so that it is as near mint as possible for a near-43 year old vinyl LP.
    I also have the original German pressing of the Mittageisen/Love in a Void single. It was released in Germany in June ’79 and imported at first. Demand was so high it was given a UK release in September.
    A large part of the appeal of this single was undoubtedly the inclusion of Love in a Void – an early staple of the Banshees’ repertoire, and somewhat infamous owing to a bootleg version that included the line ‘too many Jews for my liking’. I used to have a copy of that version on tape, but no longer. The official version is reworded ‘too many figures for my liking’. Nazi paraphernalia was favoured by some early punks, not out of genuine fascist sympathy, but for its transgressional shock value, calculated to be as antagonistic and repugnant as possible to the older generation. I remember seeing Adam and the Ants as late as mid-1979 and one fan was still sporting a swastika armband. Everyone thought he was a complete dick by then, mind you, even if they had ever thought it might have been remotely funny.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.