Seems fair, given the brilliance of some of the comments this week, to compile an imaginary match report:-

This Round begins with the band that was once my “All Time Favorite” winning and then ends with the band that usurped that position. (echorich)

A few of these matches never made it to the pitch. Most cruised to easy wins. A couple were tight, and I freely admit there was cheating with one of the matches. I voted for a hero instead of heroes. Felt sorry for him, frankly. Getting thumped.(Brian)

I’m disappointed with the way some of these results are going. Cup football really is a shocker sometimes. (swiss adam)

Blimey. Some nailbiting ties here, but equally, quite a few Stockport County v Chesterfield-type games too. Some of my ties were decided by some dodgy refereeing decisions and the influence of a shady Welsh-based betting syndicate, but here’s the full-time scores. Cue Sports Report theme and the voice of Charlotte Green…(Robster)

MGMT 3 v The Clash 37

The Clash (you could put virtually any song up against White Man In Hammersmith Palais, the answer would still be The Clash) (rigid digit)

Martin Stephenson 26 v Andrew Weatherall 10

Lord Sabre’s notorious quality pressing(s) not enough to overcome an early lead from one of the most talented teams out there. (Luca)
“It isn’t the hours you put in, but what you put in the hours!”. Easy, one of The Daintees’ finest recordings against a tune I’m probably a bit too old for …(sexy loser)

Johnny Marr 16 v Rod Stewart 23

Rod Stewart. Poor effort by Girls Aloud – perhaps if they’d stuck with their usual classic pop rather than relying on a throwaway guitar line from some guitarist or other. I mean – Ronnie Wood, Ian McLagan and Mick Waller, how do you compete with a back line of that quality. (Jacques)
Having one of the most gifted role players on your team can win you a lot of games, but this time the weight of tradition was simply too much.(Luca)
Surprised that Johnny Marr didn’t take the competition more seriously, although perhaps he’s got hopes of going all the way with his other outfit (jimdoes)
feels odd to be voting against Johnny… or FOR Rod (Rol)

Asian Dub Foundation 21 v Stars 14

ADF who have the skills to pay the bills.(wycranything)

The Durutti Column 20 v The Beta Band 15

It wasn’t a classic but Reilly at sweeper kept it tight while Mason on the other side lacked his usual verve (Jacques)
tough choice here, genuinely. But the boy Reilly edged those Betas out (bagging area)
looking at a 0-0 draw, beta band scores own goal disappointing yet again the rabid supporters who traveled to the away game (GJ)
The Beta Band’s tikitaka gave them ball possession for most of the match, but lack of focus was an issue against Vini Reilly’ s prowess (Luca)

Clyde McPhatter 20 v Gene Loves Jezebel 16

classic football here. Head up, crisp passes, executed brilliantly. Not a close match at all (GJ)
Gene Love Jezabel barely got out of the changing rooms due to over use of hair spray (jimdoes)

Grandaddy 10 v Husker Du 26

Two sides marred by tragedy this past year…the minute’s silence beforehand was impeccably observed (Malky Tucker)
A man down but Husker Du hold on till the final whistle (bagging area)

OMD 21 v Super Furry Animals 17

“There’s only a little difference between Champs and Chumps!”. A most boring game to watch, it must be said. OMD win in the end, but it was close …(sexy loser)
SFA benches their A squad and fields their B squad thinking that they will win the match easily. It doesn’t happen.(GJ)
Genuinely can’t believe SFA fielded a second-string outfit for this one. (Malky Tucker)

Teenage Fanclub 20 v Nick Cave & The Bad Seeds (2) 20

The Aussies opened up an early lead but were pegged back by Fannies on the stroke of half-time. The final few days were a war of attrition with nobody ever getting more than a goal ahead at any time.

I had an idea at least one match this week might go all the way…and so for any tie-break scenario I asked my work colleague Doog, who also happens to be the keyboard player with The Just Joans to cast some votes.  He did this on Thursday as he had the small matter of his wife Fiona giving birth on Friday!! (a boy…their second….both baby and mum are doing well!)

Doog’s shouts were Asian Dub Foundation, Beta Band, Clyde McPhatter and Daft Punk, none of which were needed. When it came to Nick v TFC, he said he couldn’t separate them.  He threw a £1 into the air which landed heads; in doing so he made this observation in a comment come true…

so painful won on toss of the coin (Bill)

Heads was The Mercy Seat by Nick Cave & The Bad Seeds.

the Bellshill Beatles couldn’t get the ball off Cave in this one (aldo)
Cave gets it as it’s a live recording and the Bad Seeds have, for years, been the best live band on the circuit (Malky Tucker)
the live version clinches it against a very strong TF track (the great gog)
Those kiddie dilettantes tried, but it was not enough to steal a win when you’re clearly not (a) Big Star. (Luca)
if you match the quality of the two centre forwards, Mercy Seat is a world class performer at every stage of his career while GKIT only really turns it on against weaker opposition. (Robster)

Roddy Frame 7 v The Stranglers 31

Frame’s midfield artistry undone by Trotsky’s devastating wing play on the left.(aldo)
love Roddy, but against the Stranglers strongest song? (Rol)
Major upset for me here but Roddy just didnt take it seriously (Matt)
Not a popular result in the commentary box (Julian Badenoch)
the Boy Wonder needs his team mates around him (charity chic)
sorry Roddy. The Stranglers didn’t send me a Christmas card, and in 1983, when I saw the Stranglers live, I was listening more to High Land, Hard Rain than No More Heroes, but that song is pure class. (nic ross)
Neil warnocks team kick the opposition all over the park. (friend of rachel worth)

Fats Comet/Tackhead 6 v The Pixies 30

non-league vs World Champions. No contest. Game abandoned at half-time due to the home team’s refusal to leave the dressing room for the second half. The H-T score was allowed to stand. (Robster)
“A ‘head(er) on’ from Francis to Deal – and it’s there. Deal scores. And it’s 1-0 to the team from Boston. And there simply will not be enough time for a response.” (strangeways)
Pixies – by a Gigantic margin (charity chic)

Yellow Magic Orchestra 13 v The Stone Roses 25

The Mancunian juggernauts needed to go on extra-time to snatch this victory from the jaws of defeat, having been initially caught completely by surprise by a not very well known Oriental team. (Luca)
Yet another difficult tie but truculent Mancunians usually win (bagging area)
“Sweat more in preparation, bleed less in battle!”. An easy task for The Roses, ‘Cos I’m afraid I’m not clever enough to understand the YMO’s tactics. Never have been, in fact! (sexy loser)

The Lucksmiths 17 v Daft Punk 23

5imply 5uperb play from the French. Against 5ome teams you just have no hope. The Lucksmiths got 5wept. (Luca)
(Un)luck(y)smith United had a stinker of a draw (Julain Badenoch)
Lucksmiths the awful victims of their opponents ability to drive a horse and carriage through the Financial Fair Play regulations and field a superstar vocalist. (Malky Tucker)

A.R. Kane 7 v The Trashcan Sinatras 27

Oh, come on, AR Kane – what a weak performance! (sexy loser)
The self proclaimed dark horses through as the opposition sound like they are all on drugs and not performance enhancing ones (jimdoes)

Coldplay 11 v The Detroit Cobras 23

No such luck for U2’s B team on the end of a severe thrashing from Detroit Cobras.(jacques)
Any team would have beaten the shower of shite that is Coldplay (jimdoes)
5 minutes of Chris Martin whining or a tune that was made by people who sounded like they were enjoying themselves? Hmmm.(the great gog)

Leonard Cohen 7 v Echo and The Bunnymen 34

And so we reach the final tie of what has been a very entertaining first round. No messing with this one. Spare Us The Clutter was always going to clean up this one. Here’s hoping star striker McCulloch can Do It Clean in the forthcoming rounds. (jacques)
A great match that went to extra time and penalties, such a shame there had to be a loser (Julian Badenoch)
Slow cool just won’t do against pure energy in a game like this (Martin)
what a match this was, the determining factor in the end being the strength of the team selection.(Robster)


I know the last four Saturdays have been a bit frantic but the staging of 16 ties was all about making the remainder of the ICA World Cup much more manageable.

The crazy nature of the draw meant that a few of the big names have gone out early on, but there’s still plenty of your favourites, dark horses and underdogs in the hat to hopefully make it still worth your while to keep an interest.

Today marks the beginning of Round 2, with 64 teams still left to battle things out. There will be just four ties per week at this stage which allows a little bit more of an in-depth look at the match-ups.

Here’s matches 1-4.

SBTRKT v The Fall

SBTRKT came through a low-scoring affair against Kanye West in Round 1 in a match which didn’t offer too many moments for the highlight reel. The Fall, represented last time by 15 Ways, lifted from what was the first ICA of the four that have featured in thes series, came through quite comfortably against Queens of the Stone Age in a tie that was played against the sad backdrop of the death of Mark E Smith. The bookies, even before the songs were selected, have made the post-punk veterans, with their huge squad to choose from, strong favourites. Maybe they were a touch premature…..

The Light (from Wonder Where We Land, 2014) v Birthday Song (from The Marshall Suite, 1999)

Kitchens of Distinction v Talking Heads

A fascinating match-up between an English band whose vocalist was born in Switzerland and an American band whose vocalist was born in Scotland. Kitchens of Distinction came through comfortably against The Indelicates last time round, thanks to Japan to Jupiter, one of the tracks from their 2013 comeback album. They are likely going to have to hope that one of their songs from their golden period of 86-96 gets onto the pitch today to face a side who have seen off two dogged and determined opponents in Close Lobsters and Massive Attack. This could all depend on the coin and dice….

Sand On Fire (from Cowboys and Aliens, 1994) v Artists Only (from More Songs About Buildings and Food, 1978)

Sonic Youth v Edwyn Collins

A tie in which both managers have been effusive about the other side’s star qualities and abilities. Sonic Youth played a dangerous game in Round 1, fielding what to many was the less than stellar I Love You Golden Blue, but it was enough to fend off Billy Joel. The former Orange Juice vocalist came through a really tough opener, knocking out Associates whom many were tipping  for a good run. Both will likely require one of their best in this round to advance any further.

mp3 : The Empty Page (from Murray Street, 2002) v If You Could Love Me (from Gorgeous George, 1994)

The Velvet Underground v Talk Talk

A really strong showing, thanks to fielding Waiting For The Man, enabled the 60s veterans to easily see off the challenge of The National last time round and on paper, they should probably have enough to get through against one of the cult UK acts of the 80s, much of whose work as featured on the ICA is far removed from the pop hits that took them into the singles charts on a couple of occasions. You could call this an intiguing match-up….especially as the former are represented by a track that is more of a jam than a finished song….

mp3 : The Booker T (from Peel Slowly and See boxset, 1995) v The Rainbow (from Spirit of Eden, 1988)

Please have your votes in by Friday 16 February but voting from now on will close at 10pm (sitting up to midnight these past four Fridays has been tough going, especially when nothing has actually happened at the last minute!!).

As ever, you don’t have to get involved in all of the ties.

Tune in next Saturday for matches 5-8, one of which may well be the hardest choice of songs you’ll have faced….thus far!



31 thoughts on “BONUS SERIES : THE ICA WORLD CUP : ROUND 2 (Part 1)

  1. Fuck, I forgot to get my votes in, not that it would have made much of a difference. There must be something in my dna that makes me support teams that look great but fail when it comes to actually winning anything. Plus ca change.

    I don’t feel sorry for the Boy Wonder, as this week he priced himself well out the market anyway, with a ridiculous fee to see him outside in Glasgow in summer when it will probably be pissing down

    I will get mine in early this week so I don’t forget but will probably put the hex on who I vote for.
    The Fall (no contest really)
    Kitchens of Distinction
    Edwyn Collins
    The Velvet Underground (not confident that Lou, John, Mo and Sterling will make it through with The Booker T maybe a bit to much technical play without putting it in the back of the net, But there is always hope)

  2. The Fall. (possible champions elect sweep aside weak opposition with ease. no sign of an upset here.)
    Kitchens Of Distinction. (In what could have been the tie of the round, the team selection was decisive. One of the Kitchens’ strongest in play here.)
    Sonic Youth. (Call me old fashioned but yearn for the days when tough tackling and good honest hard work won out on the field of play. The Youth team, being the more aggressive side, take it though credit to the plucky Scot who went down fighting.)
    Velvet Underground. (Neither side fielding a full-strength team and the tactics were often baffling but the Welsh connection in the home team made the difference in the end.)

    (By the way, I’m still smarting from the SFA result. I demand TV replays and retrospective decisions be made for the next tournament!)

  3. The final series of Round 1 ties were a varying degree of battles and walkovers, but I am pretty happy with the results.
    Now this first series of Round 2 is already tough on a fan….

    THE FALL — scare SBTRKT off the field…
    TALKING HEADS — triumph over a fully capable + ready to fight Kitchens of Distinction. This match will fill the highlight reels….
    EDWYN COLLINS — ran rings around a technically good Sonic Youth, who just chose to not show up even though they were on the pitch.
    TALK TALK — play a game of wills with The VU and come up trumps…

  4. The Fall
    Talking Heads
    Edwyn Collins – nobody beating this performance – ever
    Velvet Underground

  5. The Fall. They are Sparta FC after all. English Chelsea fan this is your last game…
    Talking Heads. Too much for KoD. Tina Weymouth takes no shit.
    SY v EC. Difficult- noise v tunes. But a weak performance by Sonic Youth sees Collins through.
    VU. Not their strongest game but the lad Morrison hit a late winner from outside the box.

    I’m still gutted that Weatherall went out early doors.

  6. Game 1 : Match abondoned when mascots started fighting
    Kitchens result causes “magic of the cup” to be mentioned repeatly on match of the day
    Edwyn how football should be played
    Talk Talk has Graham Souness frothing at the mouth

  7. ‘and its mark E Smith..Mark E Smith FC. He’s bar far the most wasted striker the world has ever seen’…
    ‘You’ll never beat the Weymouth’…
    ‘we are ripping it up, say we are ripping it up’..
    ‘we’re gunna win 3-2. we’re gunna win 3-2. we’re gunna win VU…’…

  8. The Fall – MES hagiography is still in full swing
    Talking Heads – too clever by half, and being too clever wins this one
    Edwyn Collins – a better haircut

    Velvet Underground vs Talk Talk?
    Shambolic Velvets, seemingly playing out of position, against a highly organised, well drilled Talk Talk.
    Would normally be an easy win for VU, but they make it difficult for themselves and just sneak it at the last.

  9. The Fall – although you never know the team selection or whether the main striker is blowing hot or cold
    Talking Heads even although the Distinctions throw the Kitchen Sink at them
    Edwyn – on this occasion youth does not prevail over experience
    The Velvets after a turgid midfield battle although a wee bit apprehensive about a potential doping test

  10. The Fall
    Kitchens Of Distinction (two horrible-sounding files, but only KoD made me want to find a decent copy)
    Edwyn Collins
    Velvet Underground (ground down the opposition in such a boring match, it actually felt like they’d been playing for 90 minutes)

  11. SBTRKT (It’s what MES would have wanted)
    KoD (Far better than the one-dimensional Heads)
    EC (A genuinely classy performance…may regret not keeping this one back for future rounds)
    TT (In fact I’m calling for Reed & co to be disqualified from the competition for such a half-arsed piece of pretentious crap.

    Malky Tucker

  12. The Fall – Not much of a match here, the smart wager was for the Fall to win and, well The Fall win.
    Talking Heads – Another boring match, but unlike the match where The Fall win easily, here the play was uninspired.
    Sonic Youth – The crowd expects EC to win. The Refs expect EC to win. Never has there been such a favorite. SY holds their own as the EC struggles to run with the crown placed on his head.
    TT – The crowd scratches their head as VU plays one of the worst matches in ICA cup history. Hoping to see a glimmer of talent from the front line of Reed-Tucker-Morrison, the crowd is very disappointed. VU should have gone deep into the tourney but fall ungracefully.

  13. Fewer tracks to listen to, but it’s taken me longer to respond! Another busy old weekend to blame.
    Fall (not one of their best by any stretch, but the opposition was decidedly National League North standard)
    Talking Heads (I like the KoD track, but Byrne and co’s Premier League quality sees them through)
    Edwyn Collins (as per Talking Heads)
    Velvet Underground (reminds me that I ought to write a True Confessions piece on the Spirit Of Eden album at some point)

  14. The Fall
    Kitchens of Distinction
    Sonic Youth
    The Velvet Underground – the authorities should investigate this game as it looked like both teams were trying to throw it with own goals and penalties galore! Luckily for VU the ref turned a blind eye to the fight between by Reed + Cale so both will be available in the next round – truly awful by two legendary squads.

  15. Some home bankers despite The Fall playing a weakened team – well they have a big squad to keep happy

    The Fall

  16. More personal observations this time. Probably too sarcastic even, sorry.

    SBTRKT vs The Fall
    Two bands I care not much about. I’ve heard ten better songs than the SBTRKT one in the last half hour and The Fall tune sounds like a bad Grid b-side. No vote.

    Kitchens Of Distinction vs Talking Heads
    Contrary to Echorich, apart from a few tunes I love my Talking Heads from “Fear Of Music” onwards. The Kitchens get my approval but theirs’ not a mindblowingly good song.

    Sonic Youth vs Edwyn Collins
    “The Empty Page” is simply beautiful and catchy, the kind of tune you find yourself humming all day long, but I like the Edwin Collins one a little bit more. It’s the trumpet in the chorus, surely. Both million times better than the previous match-ups.

    Velvet Underground vs Talk Talk
    The Velvets’ one is a blues workout which gets a resounding MEH from me; “The Rainbow” is better but after a promising start seems to wander aimlessly. My vote goes to Talk Talk but my cynical side tells me that maybe they’re just the Radiohead it’s okay to like.

  17. Brian- I think I remember reading that one, but so long after the event I didn’t comment. I may do a TC anyway, just so I can exorcise my own demons on SoE, and possibly get some instruction as to what it is exactly that I’m not “getting” on the admittedly infrequent occasions when I attempt to listen to it

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.